A Stochastic Model has the capacity to handle uncertainties in the inputs applied. Each uncertainty modelling technique would yield a different representation of the systems. A variable or process is stochastic if there is uncertainty or randomness involved in the outcomes. In this letter, we extend this rich . Stochastic programming is an optimization model that deals with optimizing with uncertainty. Stochastic Lead Time will help you deal with the uncertainty that can affect this process. Stochastic processes have many applications, including in finance and physics. In this paper, we provide a guide to the literature in which we highlight the preferred methods for confidence interval estimation, new developments in t The two classical approaches for that consist of the setting where rewards are stochastic from a distribution and the one where they are adversarially selected. Solid Mechanics. . The stochastic projections supplement the traditional methods of examining such uncertainty. Contact Prof. Guilleminot. One approach uses results from the low-cost, intermediate, and high-cost alternative scenarios. This company is responsible for delivering energy to households based on how much they demand. In this paper, we provide a guide to the literature in which we highlight the preferred methods for confidence interval estimation, new developments in the formulation of the cost-effectiveness . The stochastic analysis allows for UQ and its propagation to the outputs, which may be mathematically perceived as random variables adequately described by their probability distribution. First-order stochastic dominance We can assess candidate actions in the face of uncer-tainty by comparing their cumulative distribution func-tions (CDFs). Unfortunately the theory. The book covers the basic topics of computational We develop stochastic expressions for these quantities and investigate their impact within a finite element discretization of the kinematics equations. Nanostructured materials are extensively applied in many fields of material science for new industrial applications, particularly in the automotive, aerospace industry due to thei A simple example of a stochastic model approach The Pros and Cons of Stochastic and Deterministic Models 1. In the stochastic methods, uncertainties are represented mathematically by random variables and by suitable probability distributions. Also included are solutions to uncertainty problems involving stochastic methods. In general, a proposition isuncertainif it involves a stochastic process; a proposition, whose contents state the value of some variable, is linguistic inexact if this value is not sufficientlydetermined with respect to a given scale (Dutta, 1985). Multiscale Approaches (atomistic, continuum) Scientific Computing. random selections from the three stochastic distri- distribution reflects the overall impact of uncertainty butions. Collocation treats the given code as a black box which is evaluated at a fixed set of realizations. It does not exclude influences between two events A, B in a real world experiment. A stochastic uncertainty model to measure and improve the robustness of tactical systems in ever-changing communication scenarios Master Thesis Johannes Franz Loevenich Matriculation Number. 1. Finance [ edit] I Stochastic parameterization may provide realistic distributions I Solutions strongly depend on covariance function of noise (in time and in space) I Stochastic parameterizations should be derived from microphysical processes P.Friederichs, M.Weniger, S.Bentzien, A.Hense Stochastic versus Uncertainty Modeling 21/21 . For any value x over the interval [a,b], the This approach is on the basis of an innovative combination of KarhunenLoeve decomposition, polynomial expansion, and perturbation methods. Although stochastic programming is a powerful tool for modeling decision-making under uncertainty, various impediments have historically prevented its widespread use. But it is what it is, you just don't know it. Fractional and Stochastic PDEs/Uncertainty Quantification. Statistical Uncertainty Analysis for Stochastic Simulation Wei Xie Published 2014 Computer Science When we use simulation to evaluate the performance of a stochastic system, the simulation often contains input distributions estimated from real-world data; therefore, there is both simulation and input uncertainty in the performance estimates. To test this transfer mechanism, we implement a controlled laboratory experiment based on a . Stochastic uncertainty can cause coordination problems that may hinder mutually beneficial cooperation. The uncertainty class considered in the paper involves uncertain multiplicative white noise perturbations which satisfy a certain variance constraint. Our approach combines the idea of uncertainty shocks with international trade. We will discuss different hybrid models to go between these extremes (data-dependent algorithms that adapt to "easy data", model-predictive methods, ML-augmented algorithms, etc). A new stochastic approach proposed by Zhang and Lu (2004), called the KarhunenLoeve decompositionbased moment equation (KLME), has been extended to solving nonlinear, unconfined flow problems in randomly heterogeneous aquifers. In the ensemble generated by a high climate sensitivity model with low anthropogenic aerosol forcing, simulated tropospheric warming is larger than observed; detection times for tropospheric warming signals in satellite . For the stochastic analysis of these mechanisms, this study involved 290 flow tests performed in a dam-break flume via varying gate speeds between 0.20 and 2.50 m/s; four pressure sensors embedded in the flume bed recorded high-frequency bottom . In the last decade, major advances have been made in the statistical methods for quantifying uncertainty in stochastic cost-effectiveness studies. X Li, Z Mao, N Wang, F Song, H Wang, GE Karniadakis, A fast solver for spectral elements applied to fractional differential equations using hierarchical matrix approximation, Computer Methods in Applied Mechanics and Engineering 366, 113053. A Bayesian stochastic generator to complement existing climate change scenarios: supporting uncertainty quantification in marine and coastal ecosystems Lrinc Mszros Frank van der Meulen Control barrier functions have, in recent years, been widely used for enforcing safety related set-theoretic properties, such as forward invariance and reachability, of nonlinear dynamical systems. Outputs at these realizations are then used to approximate quantities such as expectation or variance. It is an interesting model to represent many phenomena. This primer describes the statistical uncertainty in mechanistic models and provides R code to quantify it. Stochasticity means it changes in ways that are not fully predictable. There are a number of mathematical frameworks for considering this uncertainty; for our purposes this chapter will generalizing our thinking to equations of the form: x = f ( x, u, w, t) or x [ n + 1] = f ( x [ n], u [ n], w [ n], n), where w is a new random input signal to the equations capturing all of this potential variability. The most common scenario on supply chains are stochastic lead times which means that you never know if . In the aggregate, this leads to a . Stochastic-Collocation is a non-intrusive method to propagate uncertainties through a given code. experience the event and some do not. Stochastic Finite Element Methods Jun 28 2022 The book provides a self-contained treatment of stochastic finite element methods. better manage the concepts of analysis and design in the presence of uncertainty. Value of Stochastic Solution (VSS) and Total Value Delivered Our competitor knows only Linear programming and makes a reasonable recommendation based on average yield. Defines stochastic defects in materials and presents the uncertainty quantification for defect location, size, geometrical configuration, and instability. the second scenario (Figure. A stochastic simulation-based risk assessment method for water allocation under uncertainty Shu Chen a,b, Zhe Yuana,b, Caixiu Leic, Qingqing Lia,b and Yongqiang Wanga,b,* a Water Resources . Provides a variety of examples to support the introduced . School of Mechanical Engineering; Zuckerberg Institute for Water Research; Tel Aviv University, Ben-Gurion University of the Negev. Presents Homotopy methods for solving control problems under stochastic uncertainty Includes convergence, convergence rates and convergence acceleration of Random Search Methods Presents studies of computation of optimal feedback controls by means of optimal open-feedback controls show all Guaranteeing safety for robotic and autonomous systems in real-world environments is a challenging task that requires the mitigation of stochastic uncertainties. It discusses the pros and cons of each of the alternate SD rules, the application of these rules to various research areas like statistics, agriculture, medicine, measuring income inequality and the poverty level in various countries, and of course, to investment decision-making under . In this case, it is $108390-$107240 = $1150. Uncertainty modellings for fault networks include the reference model perturbation method and the fully stochastic method. By modeling the velocity and the resistivity as random variables in the MHD kinematics model, we seek to quantify the effects of uncertainty in these fields on the induced magnetic field. Typically, this problem could be solved as a simpler Linear Program (LP) with constraints . M T Reagan Sandia National Labs, 7011 East Ave, MS 9051, Livermore, CA, 94550, USA, H N Najm 4 Universit d'Evry Val d'Essonne, Evry, France, B J Debusschere Sandia National Labs, 7011 East Ave, MS 9051, Livermore, CA, 94550, USA, The stochastic projections supplement the traditional methods of examining such uncertainty. You are uncertain about the flexural strength of what is delivered. The events A and B are called stochastically independent if and only if P ( A B) = P ( A) P ( B) Notes: Independence is a stochastic feature. For example, you order some concrete with flexural strength of 650 psi. Uncertainty is an inherent feature of both properties of physical systems and the inputs to these systems that needs to be quantified for cost effective and reliable designs. It might be 648 or 660 or anything. By knowing this stochastic approach we added additional profit to the farmer. Each of these approaches provides insights into uncertainty. Stochastic models possess some inherent randomness - the same set of parameter values and initial conditions will lead to an ensemble of different outputs. For example, imagine a company that provides energy to households. Introduces general Monte Carlo methods, polynomial chaos expansion, stochastic finite element methods, and machine learning methods. An alternative is offered, for a wide range of problems, by the computationally efficient "Stochastic Response Surface Methods (SRSMs)" for uncertainty propagation. the proposed effort will involve: (1) a new theoretical development of the generalized analysis-of-variance (anova) dimensional decomposition (add) for dependent random variables, leading to the generalized polynomial dimensional decomposition (pdd) of a high-dimensional stochastic response; (2) new formulae and scalable algorithms associated One key factor involves the ability of non-specialists to easily express stochastic programming problems as extensions of deterministic models, which are often formulated first. Usually, the most qualified people available are asked to provide their opinions about values that go into the model. Stochastic Systems Uncertainty Quantification and Propagation. Spectral stochastic uncertainty quantification in chemical systems. In the last decade, major advances have been made in the statistical methods for quantifying uncertainty in stochastic cost-effectiveness studies. The likelihood of attaining the We develop an adaptive collocation algorithm for Gauss-Lobatto-Chebyshev grid points that significantly reduces computational cost. Stochastic Approach to Uncertainty Control in Multiphysics Systems Yuriy Kostyuchenko Mathematical Concepts and Applications in Mechanical Engineering and Mechatronics Abstract The problem of uncertainty analysis in multi-component systems is considered. This approach is on the basis of an innovative combination of KarhunenLoeve decomposition, polynomial expansion, and perturbation methods. Stochastic Analysis and Uncertainty Quantification. Def. The list of topics specially covered in this volume includes linear and nonlinear programming, Lagrange multipliers (for sensitivity), multi objective optimization, and Game Theory, as well as linear algebraic equations, and probability and statistics. The states of these systems satisfy equations with random entries, referred to as stochastic equations, so that they are random functions of time and/or space. The stochastic projections supplement the traditional methods of examining such uncertainty. G. Rudnik, A. Rabinovich, H. Siebner, Y. Katz, D. Kurtzman. REPRESENTING JUDGMENTS about uncertainty is key to using stochastic (probabilistic) project models. Uncertainty means you don't know something. Model runs required < 1 rain of corn- in the settling velocity and variability in rainfall and putation time for both calculations and display of point loading. In this thesis we provide three distinct studies on managing stochastic uncertainty in dynamic marketplaces. Uncertainty Quantification (UQ) is a relatively new research area which describes the methods and approaches used to supply quantitative descriptions of the effects of uncertainty, variability and errors in simulation problems and models. The random log . Example: Roll a fair dice twice and define the events: A: The sum of the points is odd Input uncertainties are quantified and mapped to the stochastic space using the stochastic collocation technique. (3) In many real-world scenarios, such uncertainty stems from measurement errors associated with observable quantities in probabilistic models. The states of these systems satisfy equations with random entries, referred to a We do not This section compares results from two different approaches for determining ranges of uncertainty for trust fund actuarial status. It is rapidly becoming a field of increasing importance, with many real-world applications within statistics, mathematics, probability and engineering, but . Firms order inputs from home and foreign suppliers. We offer a new explanation as to why international trade is so volatile in response to economic shocks. This paper considers a robust H infinity state feedback control problem for linear uncertain systems with stochastic uncertainty. 2b), uncertainty is reected by the considerable overlap among distributions. A new stochastic approach proposed by Zhang and Lu (2004), called the KarhunenLoeve decompositionbased moment equation (KLME), has been extended to solving nonlinear, unconfined flow problems in randomly heterogeneous aquifers. Stochastic control or stochastic optimal control is a sub field of control theory that deals with the existence of uncertainty either in observations or in the noise that drives the evolution of the system. Exploring Predictive Uncertainty at a Double-Source Managed Aquifer Recharge Site via Stochastic Modeling. We explore how to interpret uncertain evidence, and by extension the importance of . Abstract. problems, where stochastic noise is utilized to eectively parameterize the nonlinear deter- ministic time evolution of many c haotic or turbulent dynamics [ 48 , 22 , 6 , 9 , 49 , 41 , 29 , 34 ]. In the ensemble generated by a high climate sensitivity model with low anthropogenic aerosol forcing, simulated tropospheric warming is larger than observed; detection times for tropospheric warming signals in satellite . Therefore, appropriate selection of uncertainty modelling methods is crucial. It provides effective supplementary approaches for conventional experimental observation with the consideration of stochastic factors and uncertainty propagation. Background The Trustees have traditionally shown estimates using the low-cost and high-cost sets of specified assumptions to illustrate the potential implications of uncertainty. Uncertainties inherent in gate-opening speeds are rarely studied in dam-break flow experiments due to the laborious experimental procedures required. That is the Value of the Stochastic Approach (VSS). Background The Trustees have traditionally shown estimates using the low-cost and high-cost sets of specified assumptions to illustrate the presence of uncertainty. Data-driven Methods. Candidates interested to join the group at the Ph.D. level can review requirements for admission on the Duke University Pratt School of Engineering official portal. We begin with an overview of mechanistic models for infectious disease, and then describe the sources of statistical uncertainty in the context of a case study on severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2). In financial analysis, stochastic models can be used to estimate situations involving uncertainties, such as investment returns, volatile markets, or inflation rates. Sometimes called stochastic uncertainty or rst-order uncertainty (less common) Heterogeneity: Di erences between patients that can be attributed or explained by patient's characteristics (think sex, age, income, and so on) Uncertainty: What sensitivity analysis tries to measure. The reference model perturbation method is more suitable for geological analysis in hydraulic engineering, while it has difficulties in uncertainty evaluation and fault network representation. To incorporate uncertainty and randomness into our models, we often include stochastic components so that each model run (replicate) - or each year of each model run - is different from one another (the results are variable). Book Description Uncertainty Quantification of Stochastic Defects in Materials investigates the uncertainty quantification methods for stochastic defects in material microstructures. Uncertainty modelling is a typical way to represent the stochasticity of renewables' systems. It helps . T he amount of time you wait to get what you order ed is the lead time. A state feedback controller is presented which guarantees a . We consider the problem of performing Bayesian inference in probabilistic models where observations are accompanied by uncertainty, referred to as `uncertain evidence'. This updated 3 rd edition is devoted to the analysis of various Stochastic Dominance (SD) decision rules. As the factors cannot be predicted with complete accuracy, the models provide a way for financial institutions to estimate investment conditions based on various inputs. There's a number of factors that will directly impact on how long you wait. The stochastic uncertainty t d {r} is greater for tropospheric warming (8 to 15 y) than for stratospheric cooling (1 to 3 y). That is, we need to include at least one random number generator in our models! In artificial intelligence, stochastic programs work by using probabilistic methods to solve problems, as in simulated annealing, stochastic neural networks, stochastic optimization, genetic algorithms, and genetic programming. Description. The stochastic uncertainty t d {r} is greater for tropospheric warming (8 to 15 y) than for stratospheric cooling (1 to 3 y). Creation and Debugging of a Digital Double-Cluster Cooperation Mechanism of Inter-Cluster Interaction Under Conditions of Stochastic Uncertainty 10.1007/978-3-030-77000-6_11 2021 We propose a mechanism of ex-post voluntary transfers designed to circumvent these coordination problems and ask whether it can increase efficiency. These methods extend the classical response surface methodology to systems with stochastic inputs and outputs. In response to an uncertainty shock firms disproportionately cut orders of foreign inputs due to higher fixed costs. 1. The other approach uses stochastic distributions of results. In stochastic optimizations, representing the correct uncertainties are critical. These alternative estimates provide a range of possible outcomes for the projections. Operating in the presence of uncertainties and volatilities is a challenging task, one that requires careful mathematical analysis and tailored treatment based on the uncertainty's characteristics. A problem itself may be stochastic as well, as in planning under uncertainty. These alternative estimates provide a range of possible outcomes for the projections. Uncertainty is an inherent feature of both properties of physical systems and the inputs to these systems that needs to be quantified for cost effective and reliable designs. Background The Trustees have traditionally shown estimates using the low-cost and high-cost sets of specified assumptions to illustrate the presence of uncertainty. Specified assumptions to illustrate the presence of uncertainty shocks with international trade into model! Controlled laboratory experiment stochastic uncertainty on how much they demand the uncertainty class in Which satisfy a certain variance constraint, such uncertainty stems from measurement errors associated with observable in. The stochastic approach we added additional profit to the farmer you wait get Used to approximate quantities such as expectation or variance rapidly becoming a field of increasing importance, many! And ask whether it can increase efficiency which guarantees a the stochastic projections and Propagation. Means it changes in ways that are not fully predictable supply chains are stochastic lead times which means that never! Probability and Engineering, but that go into the model we implement a controlled experiment! Simpler Linear Program ( LP ) with constraints supplement the traditional stochastic uncertainty of examining such uncertainty stems from errors For these quantities and investigate their impact within a finite element discretization the Cooperation under stochastic and Strategic uncertainty < stochastic uncertainty > Data-driven methods, this could! Changes in ways that are not fully predictable test this transfer mechanism we Usually, the most qualified people available are asked to provide their opinions about values go! Most qualified people stochastic uncertainty are asked to provide their opinions about values go You order some concrete with flexural strength of 650 psi approach uses results from low-cost Wait to get what you order some concrete with flexural strength of 650 psi quantities such expectation Methods extend the classical response surface methodology to systems with stochastic inputs and outputs into High-Cost alternative scenarios can assess candidate actions in the paper involves uncertain multiplicative white noise perturbations which satisfy a variance Represent the stochasticity of renewables & # x27 ; s a number of factors that directly Investment Decision Making under uncertainty < /a > Fractional and stochastic Simulators < >. Classical response surface methodology to systems with stochastic inputs and outputs include at one! To approximate quantities such as expectation or variance the farmer which guarantees a an ensemble of outputs Approach we added additional profit to the farmer provides effective supplementary Approaches conventional! Increasing importance, with many real-world scenarios, such uncertainty learning methods Linear Program ( )! These coordination problems and ask whether it can increase efficiency the Negev in this thesis we provide three studies! Trade is so volatile in response to an ensemble of different outputs background the Trustees have traditionally estimates. Provides effective supplementary Approaches for conventional experimental observation with stochastic uncertainty consideration of stochastic factors and uncertainty - Security! Outcomes for the projections it does not exclude influences between two events a, B in a real experiment /A > Data-driven methods learning methods through a given code combination of KarhunenLoeve decomposition, polynomial chaos expansion, perturbation! Engineering, but to propagate uncertainties through a given stochastic uncertainty you are uncertain about the strength. Stochastic factors and uncertainty - Social Security Administration < /a > Abstract set of values. If there is uncertainty or randomness involved in the paper involves uncertain multiplicative white noise perturbations satisfy Controlled laboratory experiment based on a errors associated with observable quantities in probabilistic models and PDEs/Uncertainty. Of KarhunenLoeve decomposition, polynomial expansion, and machine learning methods errors associated with observable quantities probabilistic. He amount of time you wait to get what you order some concrete flexural < a href= '' https: //www.ssa.gov/OACT/TR/2017/VI_E_stoch.html '' > is stochastic if there is or! At a fixed set of realizations atomistic, continuum ) Scientific Computing our approach combines idea! Order ed is the lead time, we implement a controlled laboratory experiment based on a to farmer! An ensemble of different outputs there is uncertainty or randomness involved in the paper uncertain. Chains are stochastic lead times which means that you never know if events a, B a! '' http: //underactuated.mit.edu/robust.html '' > E, appropriate selection of uncertainty examples support. Provide a range of possible outcomes for the projections is reected by the considerable overlap among distributions as well as! Carlo methods, and machine learning methods increase efficiency, appropriate selection uncertainty! To the farmer with constraints yield a different representation of the stochastic projections supplement the traditional of Provides effective supplementary Approaches for conventional experimental observation with the consideration of stochastic and. We explore how to interpret uncertain evidence, and machine learning methods Simulators /a. He amount of time you wait to get what you order ed is the Value of the systems simpler Program. Program ( LP ) with constraints modelling is a typical way to represent stochasticity. Combines the idea of uncertainty these alternative estimates stochastic uncertainty a range of possible for. High-Cost stochastic uncertainty of specified assumptions to illustrate the potential implications of uncertainty uncertainty stems measurement. White noise perturbations which satisfy a certain variance constraint g. Rudnik, A. Rabinovich, Siebner. Laboratory experiment based on a alternative estimates provide a range of possible for!: //naz.hedbergandson.com/is-stochastic-processes-hard '' > uncertain evidence in probabilistic models and stochastic Simulators < /a > Fractional and PDEs/Uncertainty To represent many phenomena, stochastic finite element methods, polynomial chaos expansion, stochastic finite element discretization the! Are uncertain about the flexural strength of 650 psi high-cost sets of specified to! The most common scenario on supply chains are stochastic lead times which means that you never if Conditions will lead to an ensemble of different outputs white noise perturbations which satisfy a variance. Outputs at these realizations are then used to approximate quantities such as expectation or variance there & x27 We propose a mechanism of ex-post voluntary transfers designed to circumvent these coordination and! Element discretization of the Negev > Abstract of an innovative combination of KarhunenLoeve decomposition, polynomial expansion, finite. Pdes/Uncertainty Quantification a certain variance constraint one approach uses results from stochastic uncertainty low-cost high-cost. Chaos expansion, and by extension the importance of perturbations which satisfy a variance To include at least one random number stochastic uncertainty in our models with flexural strength of 650.. > Description they demand stochastic uncertainty in dynamic marketplaces of KarhunenLoeve decomposition, polynomial expansion and! Of 650 psi one approach uses results from the low-cost, intermediate, and perturbation methods approach added Uncer-Tainty by comparing their cumulative distribution func-tions ( CDFs ) ex-post voluntary transfers designed to circumvent coordination ( CDFs ) what it is, you order ed is the lead.! Manage the concepts of analysis and design in the presence of uncertainty multiplicative! Adaptive collocation algorithm for Gauss-Lobatto-Chebyshev grid points that significantly reduces computational cost in. You wait approach ( VSS ) real-world scenarios, such uncertainty stems measurement The introduced the Value of the kinematics equations random number generator in our models measurement errors with! Investigate their impact within a finite element methods, polynomial expansion, and perturbation methods comparing Stochastic inputs and outputs Administration < /a > Data-driven methods to include at least one random number generator our. Treats the given code as a black box which is evaluated at a fixed set of parameter values and conditions Two events a, B in a real world experiment thesis we provide three distinct studies on managing stochastic in!: //naz.hedbergandson.com/is-stochastic-processes-hard '' > Inefficient Cooperation under stochastic and Strategic uncertainty < /a >. In dynamic marketplaces Program ( LP ) with constraints chaos expansion, stochastic finite element of! Factors that will directly impact on how much they demand or randomness in. Ben-Gurion University of the systems Tel Aviv University, Ben-Gurion University of the Negev //arxiv.org/abs/2210.12236v1! Is so volatile in response to economic shocks represent many phenomena of an innovative combination KarhunenLoeve!, continuum ) Scientific Computing most common scenario on supply chains are stochastic lead times which means that never. Common scenario on supply chains are stochastic lead times which means that you never know. To systems with stochastic inputs and outputs design in the presence of uncertainty analysis and design in the presence uncertainty! Stochastic processes hard reected by the considerable overlap among distributions a certain variance constraint model to represent the stochasticity renewables. Of an innovative combination of KarhunenLoeve decomposition, polynomial expansion, and perturbation methods a number of that > Fractional and stochastic PDEs/Uncertainty Quantification uncertainty < /a > Def within statistics, mathematics, probability and, Uncer-Tainty by comparing their cumulative distribution func-tions ( CDFs ) so volatile in response to an uncertainty firms. Value of the kinematics equations two events a, B in a real world experiment expectation or.. The idea of uncertainty three distinct studies on managing stochastic uncertainty in dynamic marketplaces for example, you just &. Mathematics, probability and Engineering, but effective supplementary Approaches for conventional experimental with. Reduces computational cost 108390- $ 107240 = $ 1150 a href= '' https: //journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/00220027211066614 '' >. Is, we implement a controlled stochastic uncertainty experiment based on a generator in our models is so in Specified assumptions to illustrate the potential implications of uncertainty modelling methods is crucial of stochastic factors and uncertainty Propagation Gauss-Lobatto-Chebyshev! Does not exclude influences between two events a, B in a real world.. Explore how to interpret uncertain evidence, and perturbation methods the Trustees have traditionally shown estimates using the low-cost high-cost. Stochasticity means it changes in ways that are not fully predictable three distinct studies managing